NASAA and Members of Congress Come Together on the Need for the SEC to Expand Intrastate Crowdfunding Rules

By Samuel S. Guzik, CrowdFundBeat special guest editor,  Guzik & Associate

It is rare that I am able to find agreement with the publicly stated positions of the North American Securities Administrators Association (NASAA). Equally rare – members of Congress who are traditionally strong advocates for “smart” regulatory reform of capital formation by SME’s to find themselves on the same page as NASAA.  However, there appears to be a growing, even overwhelming, consensus that the SEC’s proposed rules to modify current federal restrictions on the intrastate sale of securities – are on the one hand a step in the right direction.  But on the other hand, the SEC’s rule, as proposed, does not go far enough, and places unnecessary restrictions on the ability of states to decide what is in the best interests of their constituents – free of interference from the SEC.

By way of background, on October 30, 2015, the same day that the Commission announced final investment crowdfunding rules in furtherance of Title III of the JOBS Act of 2012 to implement investment crowdfunding on a national level – it also issued for comment a proposed rule, primarily intended to facilitate investment crowdfunding at the state level – Rule 147A. Significantly, the proposed rule would allow companies to advertise their offering on the Internet, something which the SEC Staff has stated is prohibited under current Rule 147 – and much to the consternation of state regulators and securities lawyers  alike.  In doing so, the SEC proposed to limit the amount that a state could authorize under its laws to $5 million. And it also proposed to eliminate the existing rule, Rule 147, in its entirety.

On October 7, 2016, a bi-partisan group of 15 members of Congress, many members of the House Financial Services Committee, signed a letter addressed to the SEC, encouraging the Commission to finalize its rulemaking, but with some important modifications. In particular, as proposed by the Commission, the existing “safe harbor” rule, Rule 147, which would allow states to regulate offerings occurring entirely within their state, would be scrapped in its entirety, and replaced by a new rule, Rule 147A, under the Commission’s general rulemaking powers.  This approach, if adopted in the final rules, has at least two untoward effects, as regards the ability of states to fashion their own rules for intrastate offering, including intrastate investment crowdfunding.

First, of the 35 or so states which have enacted their own investment crowdfunding statutes, adoption of the Rule, as proposed, would in effect, terminate these exemptions in many of the states which enacted their exemptions based entirely upon the current rule – proposed to be eliminated – bringing intrastate crowdfunding to a halt.  Comment letters to date have almost universally requested the SEC to clarify and expand the existing Rule 147, but to retain the existing rule.  Though a technicality of sorts, failure to fix this glitch would require the large majority of states authorizing intrastate investment crowdfunding to go back to their state legislatures to incorporate any new rule which replaces the current Rule 147. And until then, intrastate crowdfunding would be shut down.

Second, though the SEC’s proposed rule makes necessary improvements, it comes with some conditions which many find unpalatable – and unnecessary. In particular, the SEC rule, as proposed, would limit the ceiling under this proposed exemption to $5 million.  Opposition to this condition has been strong, simply because this is a matter which ought to be determined by each state – on a state by state basis.

The latest missive by 15 members of the House Financial Services Committee includes Congressman and Deputy Whip Patrick McHenry, a leading proponent of the JOBS Act of 2012 and subsequent legislation, and Congressman John Carney, the original sponsor of a Bill which passed the House this year which if enacted would create a new, independent office at the SEC – Office of Small Business Advocate – and would report to the full Commission and to Congress.  Undoubtedly, their letter will signal to the SEC the need to approval final rules as expeditiously as possible nearly a year after originally proposed. So look for good things to come from the Commission in this area in the coming months.

For those who want to dig a little deeper, I am providing links to my Comment Letter to the SEC as well as the Comment Letter submitted by NASAA, both back in January 2016.

Samuel S. Guzik has more than 35 years of experience as a corporate and securities attorney and business advisor in private practice in New York and Los Angeles, including as an associate at Willkie Farr and Gallagher, a major New York based international law firm, a partner at the law firm of Ervin, Cohen and Jessup, in Los Angeles, and in the firm he founded in 1993, Guzik & Associates.


samuel guzik

Samuel S. Guzik has more than 35 years of experience as a corporate and securities attorney and business advisor in private practice in New York and Los Angeles, including as an associate at Willkie Farr and Gallagher, a major New York based international law firm, a partner at the law firm of Ervin, Cohen and Jessup, in Los Angeles, and in the firm he founded in 1993, Guzik & Associates.

Mr. Guzik has represented public and privately held companies and entrepreneurs on a broad range of business and financing transactions, both public and private. Mr. Guzik has also successfully represented clients in federal securities litigation and SEC enforcement proceedings. Guzik has represented businesses in a diverse range of industries, including digital media, apparel, health care and numerous high technology based businesses.
Guzik is a recognized authority and thought leader on matters relating to the JOBS Act of 2012 and the ongoing SEC rulemaking, including Regulation D Rule 506 private placements, Regulation A+, and investment crowdfunding. He has been consulted by Congressional members, state legislators and the U.S. Small Business Administration Office of Advocacy on matters relating to the JOBS Act and state securities matters.

Guzik & Associates

1875 Century Park East, Suite 700

Los Angeles, CA 90067

Telephone: 310-914-8600


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at [...]

TBO.comBillionaire toy executive hopes to raise $800 million via crowdfunding to save Toys R UsTBO.comIsaac Larian, the billionaire toy executive behind Bratz, Little Tikes and L.O.L. Surprise! dolls, wants to save Toys R Us. But first, he wants you to pony up. Larian, the chief execu [...]

Syfy WireLooking for Leia kicks off crowdfunding campaign for new docu-series formatSyfy WireA documentary dedicated to the girls and women who love Star Wars is taking the next step in bringing their experiences to the screen. Looking for Leia, a documentary by award-winning filmmake [...]

Solar Power WorldRE-volv crowdfunding campaign makes solar possible for East Oakland churchSolar Power WorldEast Oakland's Faith Baptist Church unveiled solar panels on Sunday, obtained through a crowdfunding campaign from the solar nonprofit RE-volv with the support of the Leona [...]

Idaho Press-TribuneWith so many teachers crowdfunding for classroom supplies, Middleton School District updates policyIdaho Press-TribuneOn March 12, the school board approved regulations requiring teachers to fill out a short form and submit it to their principal for approval before [...]

Multiple Sclerosis News TodayAmerican Brain Foundation Starts Crowdfunding Campaign to Help Fight MSMultiple Sclerosis News TodayThe American Brain Foundation has started a crowdfunding campaign to support research that could lead to treatments for multiple sclerosis and other autoimm [...]

Honolulu Star-AdvertiserIndie film 'Waikiki' seeks crowdfunding boostHonolulu Star-AdvertiserIndie film 'Waikiki' seeks crowdfunding boost. By Jason Genegabus. Posted March 22, 2018. March 22, 2018. Updated March 22, 2018 10:11am. “Waikiki,” an independent full-len [...]

KGO-TVGroup launches crowdfunding campaign for homeless on SF's Haight StreetKGO-TVTake it to the Streets has launched a $50,000 crowdfunding campaign to provide housing and services for homeless young adults. (KGO). KGO. by Juan Carlos Guerrero. Thursday, March 22, 2018 03:58PM. [...]

The Spirits BusinessDave Broom launches crowdfunding bid for whisky filmThe Spirits BusinessWhisky writer Dave Broom is seeking to raise £40,000 (US$56k) through a crowdfunding campaign to film a new documentary on whisky and Scottish culture. Dave Broom will star in the new whisky do [...]

The Student Loan ReportWhat's the Deal With Student Loans and Crowdfunding?The Student Loan ReportCrowdfunding has been one of the defining features of the modern consumer economy in the 21st Century. A ton of successful ventures, films, inventions, and even charitable causes hav [...]

CFB Finance


  • Crowdfunding
  • Crowdfund
  • Peer to Peer Lending
  • FinTech
  • Reg A+
  • Reg CF
  • Crowdfunding USA

Press Release

Sydney Armani The Revolution is Underway – Blockchain is for Real #LEVEL39 #FINTECH WORLD EURO SUMMIT EVOLUTION OF BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY APRIL 4TH LONDON Mark your calendars for Fintech World Euro Summit...…

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |