Unregistered broker-dealer services can be illegal…and costly.

By Tim Boykin Corporate Counsel at WealthForge, Crowdfund Beat Guest Contributor,

Last month, in our blog post “Unregistered? You might be breaking the law… and the SEC is watching.,” we discussed the importance of the registration requirement of Section 15(a)(1) of the ’34 Act. We suggested that Section 15(a)(1) requires registration as a broker-dealer when a person effects or induces the purchase or sale of securities. Recent SEC action suggests that the SEC is construing the registration requirement broadly and is bringing related enforcement actions.

The previous post discussed a specific SEC enforcement action involving an unregistered online platform. This post dives a bit deeper into the recently-decided outcome of that particular action and related circumstances.

On June 21, 2016, the SEC accepted a settlement offer from the respondents in that case. The related order specified the respondants must pay more than $250,000 in disgorgement and prejudgment interest and $160,000 as a civil penalty in addition to being effectively barred from the securities industry.1

The order holds Steven Muehler and his companies, called Blue Coast Securities and Alternative Securities Markets Group Corp. (“ASMG”) breached Section 15(a)(1). They also breached Section 10(b), Rule 10(b)-5, which makes it unlawful to employ manipulative and deceptive devices in connection with the purchase or sale of securities.

The order breaks the illicit conduct into broad categories:

  1. Broker-Dealer Services Offered to Small Business and Addition Broker-Dealer Activity

    Muehler and his companies marketed  securities-related offerings and solicited securities issuers. Muehler and his companies provided broker-dealer services and other “issuer services.” These services included listing the securities for sale, structuring the offering, preparing the offering documents, marketing to and screening investors and accepting investment and funds using an online portal. The respondents also claimed the securities would be available for trading via a vibrant secondary market.

  2. Customer Agreements and Transaction-Based Compensation

    Muehler offered the services for “up-front fees, monthly fees, a percentage of funds raised, and an equity stake in each issuer.” The equity stake increased in some cases based on the success of the offering.

  3. False and Fraudulent Statements, Omissions and Deceitful Conduct

    Muehler made several blatant misrepresentations, including exaggerating his prior success, stating that ASMG was a broker-dealer, and misrepresenting the status of filings and related fees, and misrepresenting the assets of his firms.  He also used a “legal@asmmarketsgroup.com” email address and made false reference to the non-existent ASMG Legal Department.

Lessons to be Learned about the 15(a)(1) Requirement

The order doesn’t give clear guidance on what activities or combination of activities ultimately gives rise to the registration requirement under Section 15(a)(1).

In this case there were several factors contributing to the sanctions the SEC accepted. Many of the activities described in the order are patently fraudulent and disingenuous. Further, the order revealed that state regulators previously sanctioned Muehler and his related companies. The respondants also received transaction-based compensation as unregistered entities, which is almost always a Section 15(a)(1) violation.

Still, the SEC specifically called out the unregistered performance of broker-dealer related-services as illegal, independent of the other illegal securities actions in the case. In cases like the one discussed here, it appears the SEC interprets the 15(a)(1) requirement broadly. Industry participants should ensure they are on firm legal footing before engaging in securities-related activity without registration or the assistance of a registered broker-dealer.
Are you unknowingly breaking the law? Read this whitepaper to better understand if you’re
required to be registered or associated with a registered broker-dealer:

Tim Boykin

Tim serves as Corporate Counsel at WealthForge with background in private practice at a full-service business law firm where he focused on transactional matters, corporate governance, and state and federal litigation.
Find me on:

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

HEADLINE NEWS

The VergeDonald Trump's terrible crowdfunding site was a microcosm of his political careerThe VergeAnd from the beginning, the site had Trump's populist edge. Zanker boasted that “the reign of Kickstarter's Brooklyn hipsters is over,” referring to Kickstarter's New [...]

Social media, crowdfunding skirmishes encapsulate Endy debateThe Herald JournalAfter that, a campaign with the same goals and the same organizer appeared on a separate crowdfunding site, FundRazr.com. This campaign also drew negative attention on social media, and after a few hours th [...]

FortuneCrowdfunding: Women Better at Raising Money Than Men Are ...FortuneA new study has found that women are generally better than men at crowdfunding.Women are better at crowdfunding than men, shows study | The ...The Independentall 3 news articles » [...]

ForbesCrowdfunding's Death Has Been Greatly Exaggerated - Creators Ship, Especially In ChinaForbesBased on recent media reports, it looks like crowdfunding is now in the "disillusionment" phase of the famous Gartner hype cycle, after peaking a few years back. I will arg [...]

Wired.co.ukAfter budget cuts, museums are crowdfunding to preserve historyWired.co.ukIn 2015, the Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum in Washington, D.C. launched its very first crowdfunding campaign to 'Reboot the Suit'. The idea was to raise much-need funds to conser [...]

How Women Trounce Men When Raising Seed Crowdfunding CapitalForbesMale entrepreneurs may account for the majority of business owners raising finance on crowdfunding platforms in the UK, but their female counterparts are far more likely to get the support they seek, new research shows. [...]

ReutersStudy says women are better at crowdfunding - ReutersReutersWomen around the world are less likely than men to tap the crowd online for money to fund their businesses and projects, but when they do they are likely to.and more » [...]

YourStory.comA crowdfunding portal ensuring total authenticity of cases, MeHelp lets you donate confidentlyYourStory.comIn March this year, Samiya Hafeez, a 22-year-old woman from Hyderabad, was arrested for running a fake crowdfunding campaign through which she collected almost Rs 22 [...]

Yahoo SportsCan crowdfunding save women's college hockey? - Yahoo SportsYahoo SportsNorth Dakota cut its women's hockey program in March, in one of the saddest and most stunning decisions to rock the sport at the collegiate level. “When you ...and more » [...]

MashableAtaribox crowdfunding plan is a giant, flapping red flagMashable"To limit risk taking, this product will initially be launched within the framework of a crowdfunding campaign," the note — translated from French — reads. It may not have been uttered by a PR mouthpiece [...]

CFB Finance

Marketwired

  • Crowdfunding
  • Crowdfund
  • Peer to Peer Lending
  • FinTech
  • Reg A+
  • Reg CF
  • Crowdfunding USA

Press Release

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |