Crowdfunding: Disclosing Both Pros and Cons?

ByTom Muller, Partner Co-Chair, Real Estate and Land @ Manatt,

Crowdfunding has grown tremendously in the past few years, and with the recent finalization by the Securities and Exchange Commission of its rulemaking under a 2012 law, there may be an even greater expansion of investor opportunities.

Traditionally, large real estate equity and debt transactions are funded by large institutions such as REITs and life insurance companies that invest in companies or joint ventures with only one or two investors. At the other end of the scale, a local real estate developer or investor might gain funding from friends and family members by way of a limited partnership structure or “sidecars.”

download (30)

Crowdfunding uses the broad reach of the Internet to attract small individual investments from a wide range of investors, many of whom have never had access to direct real estate investments because of the large individual commitments required.

Until late 2015, sponsors of real estate investments were limited in their ability to raise funds from large numbers of small investors by securities regulations requiring time-consuming and expensive securities registration and prospectuses, unless the capital raise was limited to “accredited investors”—i.e., those having a net worth over $1 million or income over $200,000.

Now, a sponsor of real estate investments can raise up to $1 million in any 12-month period from investors with little or no income or net worth, as long as the investment doesn’t exceed, for those with income below $100,000, the greater of (i) 5% of the lesser of income or net worth, or (ii) $2,000, and for investors with $100,000 or greater income and net worth, 10% of the lesser of income or net worth, capped at $150,000 for all such investments during a rolling 12-month period.

The new rules do require disclosures to investors, and the use of a broker-dealer or funding portal responsible for compliance with the offering and investment limitations and certifications, and annual reporting with the SEC. Still, this process is far more streamlined than a traditional registered offering or even the new smaller public offering now available under the securities laws.

The end result, of course, is a potentially important source of capital for smaller-end real estate investment companies, and a new and very quickly growing set of opportunities for average people to invest in real estate deals.

In creating and permitting this new source of capital and investment, the real estate industry and SEC are at the same time weighing the risks to small investors, most of whom presumably do not have a lot of experience investing in real estate deals.

Like the EB-5 program, which attracts investment to the United States from (wealthier) offshore investors with the lure of immigration status, crowdfunding will overwhelmingly appeal to very unsophisticated investors.

While some protection is provided by the limits on investment in the new regulations, it’s not hard to imagine that when some of these investments inevitably fail, there will be a lot of shocked small investors. There will also be a lot of excited class action lawyers, as the new regulations do not reduce sponsors’ liability for failure to adequately disclose the risks of these investments.

The recent articles on the use of crowdfunding for mezzanine debt highlight this, as most institutional lenders today will not touch mezzanine debt, still ruing the huge losses they suffered on those loans in the Great Recession.

For small real estate companies, crowdfunding represents a really promising new source of capital. But the unsophisticated nature of the investors mandates particular care in clearly disclosing both the pros and the cons of the deal.

Source:

https://www.manatt.com/real-estate-and-land-use/Crowdfunding-Disclosing-Both-the-Pros-and-the.aspx

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

HEADLINE NEWS

Daily MailNick Clegg crowdfunding former Deputy PM appeals donations ...Daily MailLib Dem MP Nick Cleg is 'crowdfunding' to help bankroll the publication of thousands of party leaflets for canvassing ahead of the re-election bid in Sheffield ...and more » [...]

OregonLive.comCrowdfunding efforts for Portland stabbing victims top $700000 in less than 48 hoursOregonLive.comThe crowdfunding campaigns sprang up soon after news reports spread of the attack. Two are designed to help all three families with medical costs and to alleviate any financ [...]

Android Authority (blog)Crowdfunding project of the week: BIKI is an underwater drone that ...Android Authority (blog)Drones are fun, but they can only move through air. We know plenty of you prefer to go underwater. If so, BIKI is for you.and more » [...]

Hall alone in vote against rape kit crowdfundingRockwall County Herald Banner“Rape kit testing is far too important to rely on an undependable funding source like crowdfunding. This is a core function of government and as such it should be funded by government. Victims deserve to know [...]

Virginia Tech launches its own crowdfunding site to reach new generation of donorsRoanoke TimesOne of the first four pilot projects that went live on Jump, Tech's crowdfunding website, lets users pay for as little as one local child to attend educational programming by the Moss A [...]

New York MagazineFacebook Rolls Out Crowdfunding to EveryoneNew York MagazineDepending on your perspective, the rise in popularity of crowdfunding is either a fantastic new way that the internet lets strangers help each other out, or emblematic of the decay of institutional safeguards [...]

Youris.comCrowdfunding boosts green powerYouris.comWith state subsidies falling, crowdfunding platforms are increasingly stepping in to help make green power projects a reality. For individual investors, injecting anything from a few euros to hundreds of thousands, they are a tangiabl [...]

Tech City NewsWhy are more and more tech firms turning to crowdfunding?Tech City NewsWhen Facebook bought virtual reality firm Oculus VR for £2bn (£1.3m) in 2014, the crowdfunding world looked on with amazement. Oculus, founded in California in 2012, had raised its crucial first $2m o [...]

Crowdfund InsiderResearch on Risk Shows Crowdfunding Has Significant Fraud Immunity: Here's WhyCrowdfund InsiderIt may be counterintuitive but the research has been done and the results are now in – and it's as we've been saying for almost five years. Fraud in crowdfund [...]

Finance MagnatesEthereum Alternative Æternity Starts Phase Two of Crowdfunding CampaignFinance MagnatesÆternity's blockchain is built from scratch with most of the transactions done off-chain for speed and efficiency. Avi Mizrahi | News (CryptoCurrency) | Monday, 29/05/2017|14:55 [...]

CFB Finance

Marketwired

  • Crowdfunding
  • Crowdfund
  • Peer to Peer Lending
  • FinTech
  • Reg A+
  • Reg CF
  • Crowdfunding USA

Press Release

CrowdFund Beat Media

Teacher turns to crowdfunding to buy greenhouse for Nunavut students upflow.co/l/bqoI pic.twitter.com/chHa3MnCfT

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |