Why Title II Portals Will Also Become Title III Portals, And Vice-Versa

By Mark Roderick , CrowdFund Beat   Sr. Guest  Contributor, @CrowdfundAttny.

Why has Home Depot made local hardware stores a thing of the past? Partly price, but mainly selection. And I think the same forces will require most Crowdfunding portals to offer investments under Title II, Title III, and Title IV, all at the same time.

Crowdfunding portals are like retail stores that sell securities. They have suppliers, which we call “sponsors” or “portfolio companies,” and they have customers, which we call “investors.” They pick the market they want to serve – hard money loans, for example – then try to stock their shelves with products from the best suppliers to attract the largest number of customers. Think of DSW, but selling securities rather than shoes.

Live JOBS Act Title IV REG A+ Shall We Dance ?

 

 

 

 

Now consider these situations:

  • You’re a Title II portal and have established a relationship with Sandra Smith, a real estate developer you’ve learned to trust. She informs you she’d like to raise $30 million to build a shopping center in Chicago and needs to attract investors from the local community. You could tell her you only do Title II and send her across the street, but maybe she’ll find a competitor where she can get Title II and Title IV under one roof. So you’d really like to offering Title IV as well, which means attracting non-accredited investors.
  • You’re a Title II portal raising money for biotech. A company approaches you with a new therapy for cystic fibrosis. They have 117,000 Facebook followers and wide support in the cystic fibrosis community, and have already raised $30,000 in a Kickstarter campaign. They want to raise $800,000 for clinical tests, then come back and raise $5 million if the tests are successful. Sure, you could tell them to go somewhere else for the $800,000 raise and come back for the larger (and more profitable) $5 million round, but once they leave they’re probably not coming back.
  • You’re a Title III portal with lots of investors signed up. Turned away by the portal she’s used to working with, Sandra Smith asks for your help in the $30 million Title IV raise. Any reason to turn her down?

Those of us in the industry see Title II, Title III, and Title IV as separate things, but to the suppliers and customers of the industry they’re all the same thing. The differences between Title II and Title IV are nothing compared to the differences between sneakers and 6-inch heels! Yet DSW sells them both and everything in between because in the eyes of customers, they’re all shoes.

It doesn’t matter to suppliers and customers that Title II and Title III require different technology and business models. It doesn’t matter that one is more profitable than the other. Mercedes might lose money selling its lower-end cars but doesn’t mind doing so because customers who buy the lower-end Mercedes today buy the higher-end Mercedes 10 years from now. The Vanguard Group probably loses money on some of its funds but sells them anyway to keep customers in the fold. As the Crowdfunding market develops, I think the same will be true of the interplay with Title II, Title III, and Title IV.

For portals that have achieved success in Title II, it might be unwelcome news that Title II isn’t enough. But on the positive side, Fundrise has managed to leverage its reputation in Title II into a well-received REIT under Title IV. In any case, I think it’s inevitable.

1c53d7e-1-120x120

Mark also maintains a widely-read Crowdfunding blog at crowdfundattny.com. In addition to Flaster/ Greenberg’s Crowdfunding Practice, Mark is also a member of the firm’s Mergers and Acquisitions, Business and Corporate, and Taxation Practice Groups. He represents entrepreneurs and their businesses across a wide range of industries, including technology, real estate and healthcare. Mark holds a Master’s degree in mathematics as well as a J.D. from the University of Virginia. You can reach Mark at 856.661.2265 or mark.roderick@ flastergreenberg.com.

For more information on Crowdfunding, including news, updates and links to important information pertaining to the JOBS Act and how Crowdfunding may affect your business, : @CrowdfundAttny.

 

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

nov2017-fintech confernce-dc

HEADLINE NEWS

LeaflyCrowdfunding Site Cancels Aid to California Wildfire Victims—Because CannabisLeaflyWithin days, Hezekiah Allen, CGA's founder and executive director, had set up a campaign on the San Francisco-based crowdfunding website YouCaring to collect donations to help the farmers rec [...]

Food & Wine (blog)Crowdfunding Campaign Seeks $213 Billion to Buy Anheuser-Busch InBevFood & Wine (blog)With a goal that is impossible to reach, "Take Back Craft" (as the crowdfunding campaign is called) is admittedly a marketing campaign first. Jokingly, this " [...]

RecodeCrowdfunding site Indiegogo will now let you sell products as it shifts ...RecodeIn the past, entrepreneurs on the crowdfunding site Indiegogo could offer contributors a gift in exchange for cash. Then a year ago, they could begin offering ...and more » [...]

EW.comAdam Goldberg launches crowdfunding effort for Hebrew Hammer sequelEW.comFourteen years after Adam Goldberg first donned the Jewish crimefighter's overcoat and yarmulke, the actor is ready for another round. Goldberg, director Jonathan Kesselman, and producer Harrison Huffm [...]

Phoenix Business JournalCrowdfunding comes to Arizona real estatePhoenix Business Journal“The new crowdfunding legislation has empowered all Arizonans with the opportunity to invest locally in business startups, which had been for decades, reserved for only qualified investors. Neighb [...]

ForbesThe Recipes For Crowdfunding Success On Kickstarter -- And What To AvoidForbesToo little is known about the recipes for a successful crowdfunding drive for a new product. And there is even less known about online drives, despite its meteoric success over the past decade. A 2013 [...]

YOU CAN HELP: Friends launch crowdfunding campaign for Admiral attack victim and familyWest Seattle Blog (blog)After an Admiral woman was stabbed last week while walking with her baby on 41st SW, many people asked how the community could help with her recovery. Now, there's a way [...]

Hour Detroit MagazineHow Crowdfunding is Helping Detroit Families Stay in Their HomesHour Detroit MagazineThe Tricycle Collective has a unique approach to helping Detroiters fight tax foreclosure.and more » [...]

KTUU.comWasilla police meets crowdfunding goal for new K9 OfficerKTUU.comWASILLA, Alaska (KTUU) - The Wasilla Police Department announces that enough money was raised to purchase a new police dog, following the death of K9 Marshal. The announcement comes Monday, five months after crow [...]

PR Web (press release)CCA Announces Availability Comprehensive Crowdfunding DatabasePR Web (press release)Miami, Florida (PRWEB) October 17, 2017 -- Today at a Private Capital Markets forum, Crowdfund Capital Advisors (CCA) announced immediate availability of.and more » [...]

CFB Finance

Marketwired

  • Crowdfunding
  • Crowdfund
  • Peer to Peer Lending
  • FinTech
  • Reg A+
  • Reg CF
  • Crowdfunding USA

Press Release

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |