HOW CHINA REGULATES FINANCIAL INNOVATION

by Martin Chorzempa Master (NPA/ID) Candidate HARVARD Kennedy School  CrowdfundBeat Guest post.

In this blog’s inaugural post, I outline my hypothesis about China’s regulatory approach to developments in Chinese finance. These observations are based on two years working and living in Beijing, much of which in an organization that led to frequent interaction with Chinese financial policymakers, scholars, and financiers.

Chinese reform in general has followed a time-tested method of slow liberalization, the famous “crossing the river by feeling stones” but the Internet has turned this process on its head. The internet did not exist when the command economy was in force, so the Chinese never developed a large Soviet-style bureaucracy with mountains of rules and regulations, including vested interests who would oppose all attempts at liberalization. Regulatory action is thus the opposite for the internet: the government taking no action means allowing almost anything for the Internet sector, while doing nothing in other areas meant that all burdensome restrictions remained in place.

While traditional, licensed financial institutions are tightly controlled, with bank deposit and lending rates until recently determined by the government, quantitative loan-to-deposit ratios that cap total credit from banking institutions, and a litany of others, shadow banks that dodged these pesky regulations and offered higher rates of return thrived, often with bank support or even banks selling their “wealth management products.” Especially from post-crisis to 2013, trust companies, local government financing vehicles, and other shadow banks came out onto the front page of international news, with stories of  murky investment projects and speculation as to systemic risk these mostly unregulated entities might entail.

Meanwhile, the authorities’ reactions were slow. The existing regulations seemed not to cover this type of institution, with neither China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC), China Banking Regulatory Commission (CBRC), the central bank (PBoC), or local authorities clear on who was responsible for regulating them or tallying up the scale and risk of the business they undertook. Once they had grown into such proportions that they may pose a systemic risk to China’s financial system, the authorities clamped down in 2013 without making the resulting rules public.

Though Chinese P2P was started in 2006, the sector began its true ascendancy in 2013, coincidentally as previously explosive growth in shadow banking began to decline (partly due to mid-2013 turmoil in the interbank markets they relied on for funding, partly due to increased regulation).

Operating Platforms wangdaizhijia to 1h2015

Data From Online Lending House (网贷之家)

The rise of P2P lending, a space that was virtually unregulated, led to free reign for some compelling innovation in China’s underdeveloped credit market, but also to some serious abuses and platforms under investigation for potential fraud over 1b RMB while others have simply taken in client funds and then run away with the funds. There are mixed reviews on the proposed regulations (link is Chinese only) from the China Banking Regulatory Commission released in December (which I will summarize in a later post), with some aspects criticized for being too harsh on the P2P platforms. However, it is important to recognize that this sector functioned with little to no effective formal regulation for almost 10 years, from 2006 to the end of 2015 (and compliance is only required 18 months later), and any new rules have to play catch up.

Another reason for the difficulty and delay is that previous and current regulations in the financial sector heavily relied on local governments to implement the rules. Many restrictions would be based on where a company can open a branch or conduct business, but these companies now can have branches anywhere the hundreds of millions of Chinese with smartphones carry them, reducing the effectiveness of these regulations. It is unclear whether a local finance official in Beijing/Shanghai/Shenzhen will have the time or authority to be doing audits of P2P loans or operations far outside their jurisdiction, so this approach may lead to low ability to enforce the new rules effectively.

Countries around the world are struggling with the regulation of financial innovation, with the US potentially too restrictive of innovation (for example, Lending Club cannot yet operate in every US state due to the idiosyncratic rules in each). The UK appears to be leading the way in creating an encouraging, well-regulated environment for these platforms, lead by the P2PFA, an industry association. China’s approach has been to come late into the business of regulation, and its effectiveness is yet to be seen. In future posts, I will delve more into the Chinese regulatory environment, including analyses of the major documents for P2P regulation. Stay tuned and check back in often!

Tags: , , , , ,

HEADLINE NEWS

This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at https://news.google.com/news [...]

The VergeNeill Blomkamp's Firebase crowdfunding campaign comes to an ...The VergeJust over a week after announcing its crowdfunding campaign to fund a sequel to its short concept film Firebase, Neill Blomkamp's Oats Studios has pulled the plug on the project, and says that i [...]

ForbesNeed To Fund Your Health Idea? How About Crowdfunding? - ForbesForbesGot an idea that you think will change the face of health or public health? Don't know where to go to get funding to launch the idea? Worried that you won't be able to convince one person or one organ [...]

Billy PennMore than in other cities, Philly families resort to crowdfunding for funeral costsBilly PennOf the top 45 crowdfunding campaigns in Philadelphia currently listed on the site, 25 are looking for help paying for memorials. GoFundMe recognizes the need, and even has a page ded [...]

Stuff.co.nzJeremy Elwood and Michele A'Court: Crowdfunding is like buskingStuff.co.nzStormy Daniels is currently raising US$75,000 a week through crowdfunding to cover her legal expenses against Donald Trump. OPINION: Husband-and-wife comedians and commentators Jeremy Elwood and [...]

WDJTWoman accused of stealing from crowdfunding account she set up for grieving familyWDJTMINNEAPOLIS (WCCO) — A 49-year-old Minnesota woman faces charges for allegedly stealing money from a crowdfunding account she set up for a family who suffered a loss, according to the Hennepin Co [...]

Joplin Globe'Grow with us': Empire Market launches crowdfunding effort ahead of openingJoplin GlobeTo help provide those amenities, Downtown Joplin has begun a crowdfunding effort ahead of the market's Saturday opening day. DJA was the only Joplin-based organization sel [...]

FierceBiotechCNS Pharma turns to crowdfunding to advance glioblastoma drugFierceBiotechCNS Pharma has launched a fundraising drive for a phase 2 study of a drug for glioblastoma, the form of brain cancer that has claimed the lives of Senator Ted Kennedy and Vice President Joe Biden [...]

Popular ScienceAnker's smart home brand is crowdfunding a new security systemPopular ScienceWe don't typically post about Kickstarter campaigns, but Eufy—like their parent company Anker—makes excellent products that are more reliable and interesting than the average crowdfun [...]

Crowdfund InsiderPremium Cider Brand Cranes Launches Second Equity Crowdfunding Campaign on SeedrsCrowdfund InsiderCranes, a UK-based premium cranberry cider brand, has launched its second equity crowdfunding campaign on Seedrs. The debut of the latest funding round comes less than tw [...]

CFB Finance

Marketwired

  • Crowdfunding
  • Crowdfund
  • Peer to Peer Lending
  • FinTech
  • Reg A+
  • Reg CF
  • Crowdfunding USA

Press Release

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |