Marketplace Lending Growth Hinges on Data and Analytics Capabilities

By Richard Kelly,   NewOak Managing Director, CrowdFundBeat Guest post

Last week, the Structured Finance Industry Group presented a panel discussion on marketplace lending in New York. The panel included representatives of marketplace platforms (including Lending Club, the market leader), an institutional purchaser (a fund), a rating agency and a lawyer specializing in the area. Here are a few key takeaways:


unnamed (1)

1. The sector is growing, both in loan volume and the number of new platforms, but:

      a. this growth has put pressure on both rates and underwriting standards
    b. proliferation of platforms will lead to shake-out and consolidation

2. The basic product remains the three- to five-year unsecured loan. Small-business loans and other sectors are growing, but more slowly.

3. Emphasis is on financial technology to automate the underwriting. Both platforms (which use automated processes to generate data on potential borrowers) and purchasers (who develop proprietary algorithms to identify “good” borrowers whose loans are perceived as underpriced) rely on big data capabilities to mitigate risk.

4. For platforms, the originate-to-sell model is still dominant. However, some are moving in the direction of being balance-sheet lenders who hold their own loans.

5. Although there have been and will continue to be securitizations, the dominant players are still buy-hold yield-seeking funds. Retail (the original “peer-to-peer” model) is of diminishing importance.

6. Strong preference at Lending Club and other established players for borrowers coming through origination channels (vs. “walk-ups”). Alliances with other vendors (e.g., solar panel vendors, etc.) are a big focus.

7. There is warehouse capacity and appetite: banks want to provide warehousing to fund buyers of this product.

8. On the ratings front, the focus is on:

      a. robustness and transparency of the process at the platform level
    b. servicing considerations (not yet tested in an economic downturn)

9. The Madden decision and associated usury risk is causing purchasers to exclude loans that have this risk. Loans from New York, Connecticut or Vermont that have interest rates in excess of the applicable usury rates in those states are being rejected by purchasers and excluded from securitization pools.

Overall, it appears likely that continued growth of marketplace lending platforms will hinge on the kind of data-handling capabilities needed to expand both the availability of individual credit and increase the efficiency of pricing. However, in doing so the platforms are pushing an entire sector of credit into a less heavily regulated environment (since Dodd-Frank there is no such thing as an unregulated environment involving credit) with an interesting mix of incentives that resembles the mortgage lending environment of the early 2000’s. That said, there are several notable differences:

  • There is no asset bubble to drive “irrational exuberance”
  • These are very short duration assets so problems (and there will be problems) will surface much more quickly
  • The size of the market is a small fraction of the size of the mortgage market – thus “systemic risk” is much less likely to be a factor

Successful platforms will be those that can bring together technological capabilities, analytic rigor and deep understanding of risk and credit.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Marketplace.orgCrowdfunding for your"When I took that phone call, and I learned that this was just going to completely uproot my whole life, I'd say I spent maybe 10 seconds or so only freaking out about myself and whether or not I would die. And then imm [...]

The HinduYoung Moroccans change lives with crowdfunding - The HinduThe HinduAccess to funding is vital for young Moroccan companies. Two young men have recently developed an application that enables projects to get financed by ...and more » [...]

TIMEA Crowdfunding Effort Launches to Commemorate Khadija Saye, Artist Killed in London InfernoHyperallergicOn Saturday, friends and supporters of the artist Khadija Saye — who died in the devastating Grenfell Tower fire in west London last week — launched a crowdfunding campaign to c [...]

Santa Ynez Valley NewsTrikke Tech consolidates operations in Buellton, launches ...Santa Ynez Valley NewsTrikke Tech Inc. has consolidated all its operations at a new location in Buellton and launched a crowdfunding campaign to help the company expand and ...and more » [...]

CBS NewsNow you can crowdfund a 529 college savings plan - CBS NewsCBS NewsIt's getting easier to have friends and family add their contributions to these accounts for college savings.and more » [...]

ForbesThis $130 Million Fund Is Leading The Way In Real Estate CrowdfundingForbesWhen people think of crowdfunding, the first word that jumps to mind is Kickstarter. But crowdfunding is not limited to supporting the next card game or independent film. Crowdfunding is becoming a viable [...]

Forbes"Make Yourself Available" - An Audio Entrepreneur's Tips For Successful CrowdfundingForbesIt takes a brave individual to launch Bluetooth speakers and headphones into a crowded audio market. Take a stroll around your local consumer electronics stores and you' [...]

WMFD.comLegislation Permitting Intrastate Equity Crowdfunding PassesWMFD.comCOLUMBUS, OH - State Representative Mark Romanchuk (R-Ontario) Thursday applauded the Ohio House for approving legislation that permits, in certain circumstances, intrastate equity crowdfunding, with the goal [...]

Business InsiderCrowdfunding for medical expenses - Business InsiderBusiness InsiderAlmost half of the money raised on crowdfunding sites like GoFundMe and YouCaring is going toward medical expenses. Medical campaigns make up $930 ...Americans Losing Health Insurance Turn To Crowdfund [...]

PC GamerAshes of Creation launches 'Summer Crowdfunding Extension ...PC GamerThe ambitious MMO Ashes of Creation was successfully crowdfunded in just one day last month, before ultimately accumulating a staggering $3271809—this ...and more » [...]

CFB Finance

Lst Val
+/- Val
+/- %


  • Crowdfunding
  • Crowdfund
  • Peer to Peer Lending
  • FinTech
  • Reg A+
  • Reg CF
  • Crowdfunding USA

Press Release

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |