Trash Crowdfunding?

Crowdfunding seems like such a great idea. Finally, the rank-and-file donors of America (and the world!) can pool their resources to tackleproblems that matter or support companies with great ideas but no access to start-up money. Now anyone can breathe life into someone’s creative vision. And occasionally they do: The Pebblesmartwatch and Levar Burton’s “Reading Rainbow” revival came about thanks to creditors like you.

The everyday reality is far less inspiring.

An endless stream of dubious campaigns flows through my inbox. There are projects to make potato salad or build an inflatable sculpture of Lionel Richie’s head. MyFreeImplants.com lets you crowdfund breast augmentation so you can “help the women of your dreams achieve the body of their dreams.” Trevolta.com allows you to pay for others to travel.

The problem is this: Unlike with investments in, say, SEC-compliant companies, there is simply no accountability. I want assurances that my money will back a successful endeavor, or at least a well-managed one with a detailed business plan, a budget and qualified employees in positions of authority. Once I fund a project, its creators should be required to show how they actually spent my money. Yet none of the crowdfunding platforms require these things.

Instead, money-seekers pitch to people ill-equipped to judge them, playing heavily to emotions. We want cool stuff like 3D-drawing pens or feel guilty denying a friend’s new project. It truly is wonderful to fall in love with a good cause, but more than $10 millionflows through crowdfunding sites monthly, and excitement is no check on how it’s spent. Let’s not forget, those sites make money on our feelings.

No wonder people feel no shame asking you to fund their 38 globe-trotting weddings, or their virtual-reality headset that never delivers or their games that raise half a million dollars and then die out.

While I’d love to help bring mini-robotic printers to market or help indigenous people in Burma receive medical care, the safest way to do those things is probably still to give to people who know what they’re doing. Let’s toss crowdfunding.

Leigh Shulman, a writer living in Argentina, runs Creative Revolution Retreats, writing retreats for women.

Tags:

HEADLINE NEWS

Jamaica GleanerPointers to Publishing | Consider crowdfunding to finance your bookJamaica GleanerYou have great ideas but do not have the funds, or you do not want to take the risk of taking a loan or asking for financial support from family. Crowdfunding might be your best bet, and t [...]

The VergeDonald Trump's terrible crowdfunding site was a microcosm of his political careerThe VergeAnd from the beginning, the site had Trump's populist edge. Zanker boasted that “the reign of Kickstarter's Brooklyn hipsters is over,” referring to Kickstarter's New [...]

FortuneCrowdfunding: Women Better at Raising Money Than Men Are ...FortuneA new study has found that women are generally better than men at crowdfunding.Women are better at crowdfunding than men, shows study | The ...The Independentall 3 news articles » [...]

Social media, crowdfunding skirmishes encapsulate Endy debateThe Herald JournalAfter that, a campaign with the same goals and the same organizer appeared on a separate crowdfunding site, FundRazr.com. This campaign also drew negative attention on social media, and after a few hours th [...]

ForbesWhy Crowdfunding Is Still Booming, Especially For Chinese Tech CompaniesForbesBased on recent media reports, it looks like crowdfunding is now in the "disillusionment" phase of the famous Gartner hype cycle, after peaking a few years back. I will argue that crowdfundin [...]

Wired.co.ukAfter budget cuts, museums are crowdfunding to preserve historyWired.co.ukIn 2015, the Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum in Washington, D.C. launched its very first crowdfunding campaign to 'Reboot the Suit'. The idea was to raise much-need funds to conser [...]

Business Daily (press release) (blog)How Women Trounce Men When Raising Seed Crowdfunding CapitalForbesMale entrepreneurs may account for the majority of business owners raising finance on crowdfunding platforms in the UK, but their female counterparts are far more likely to get the s [...]

Yahoo SportsCan crowdfunding save women's college hockey? - Yahoo SportsYahoo SportsNorth Dakota cut its women's hockey program in March, in one of the saddest and most stunning decisions to rock the sport at the collegiate level. “When you ...and more » [...]

road.ccCanadian cyclist charged with fraud after crowdfunding fake booby trap injuriesroad.ccA cyclist who pretended to have been injured by a barbed wire booby trap and asked for cash on a crowdfunding website has been charged with fraud and public mischief. Stelianos Psaroudakis, 37 [...]

ReutersStudy says women are better at crowdfunding - ReutersReutersWomen around the world are less likely than men to tap the crowd online for money to fund their businesses and projects, but when they do they are likely to.and more » [...]

CFB Finance

Marketwired

  • Crowdfunding
  • Crowdfund
  • Peer to Peer Lending
  • FinTech
  • Reg A+
  • Reg CF
  • Crowdfunding USA

Press Release

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |