What the SEC Can Learn from Intrastate Crowdfunding?

By Irene Tordera, CrowdFunding Beat Guest Editor, 
Two years have almost passed since the SEC was supposed to put in place a set of crowdfunding rules as indicated by the JOBS Act which was signed earlier in 2012. The US Congress, in fact, had put December 2012 as a deadline for the SEC to approve and release crowdfunding rules. Since then, the SEC published a drafted legal framework for this new financial tool last year and, after having received several comments from the public, went silent again.
But why the SEC is taking so long? Put in simple words, one of the main reasons is probably that it is not convinced by the idea of opening, with a too light regulation, securities crowdfunding to a “crowd” of non investment-savvy citizens, because it considers it a risky activity and wants to find the best way possible to guarantee the maximum protection to retail investors,on the one hand, without losing the potential of crowdfunding as an SME finance source on the other hand.
However, if on the one side the SEC is taking its time to create and approve a set of rules for securities crowdfunding, on the other side, the growing US crowdfunding ecosystem can’t wait to see some action. And this is why the states took action to fill in the void left by the SEC’s cautiousness, creating the so called “intrastate crowdfunding” movement.
Thirteen states have so far adopted a legislation for crowdfunding, all of them with the same objective of fostering access to finance for SMEs, but with different rules and requirements depending on the state.
Does intrastate crowdfunding actually work? Difficult to tell exactly, since many states adopted their set of rules only very recently. However, some securities crowdfunding portals have already launched their activities exploiting one or the other state regulations and even closing some deals. Was there any fraud? No, until now.
Which does not mean that there is no risk of frauds, but only that it is a good start. Also looking outside the US, in Europe, for example, where different countries have opened securities crowdfunding also to retail investors, there is no big case of fraud.
Implementing a good set of rules at national level may help fostering transparency in a mechanism like crowdfunding which is already transparent by nature. If the different intrastate rules may be seen from a federal perspective as an experiment to test what actually works fine to help establish a flourishing and transparent crowdfunding market and what actually does not, the SEC may be learning a lot from these initiatives for its future regulation.
Immagine

About the author – Irene TorderaBorn and raised in Milan, Italy, Irene is an International Business graduate, with a strong interest for innovative ideas that can simplify our lives.  During her studies, she co-founded an online community for sportspeople and worked in marketing positions at Ogilvy & Mather Advertising and at the European Business Angel Network, in Brussels. She is a passionate blogger about crowdfunding and the startup ecosystem.
This article was also publish on Crowd Valley

Tags: , , , ,

HEADLINE NEWS

Types of Crowdfunding for your Small Business  Small Business TrendsFor small businesses looking to bypass traditional sources of financing, crowdfunding is a great choice. Here's a quick primer on the types of crowdfunding. [...]

Northern Monk completes rebrand after £1.5m crowdfunding campaign  The Drinks BusinessLeeds-based brewery Northern Monk has completed a rebrand of its range and released new gluten-free and low-alcohol beers after raising £1.5 million in 13 ... [...]

Crowdfunding offers promise for women and junior academics  Times Higher Education (THE)Study's authors suggest women are better able to communicate the value of science to score public donations. [...]

Unpaid Fyre Festival Cook Wins Back Life Savings From Crowdfunding Campaign  TheWrapMaryann Rolle, who appeared in Netflix documentary "Fyre," earned over $139000, surpassing her $123000 fundraising goal. [...]

How To Set Yourself Up For Crowdfunding Success  ForbesIf you want your crowdfunding venture to become a wild success, it's important to prepare to give yourself the best shot. [...]

How Crowdfunding Works For Entrepreneurs  ForbesHow does crowdfunding work for startup entrepreneurs? Crowdfunding exploded onto the internet a few years ago. Since then early platforms like Kickstarter ... [...]

Woman crowdfunding to have vaginal mesh removed  BBC NewsVictoria Adams is crowdfunding to have it removed after the NHS refused to do so. [...]

Syrian refugee attack: Boy's family crowdfunding to sue Tommy Robinson and Facebook over 'defamation'  The IndependentLawyers representing a Syrian boy who was attacked at school are crowdfunding to sue Tommy Robinson and Facebook. Footage of the 15-year-old victim ... [...]

How Crowdfunding Is Helping Homeless People Turn Their Lives Around  ForbesUK-based tech startup Beam has developed a crowdfunding platform that's helping homelessness people upskill and pursue successful careers. [...]

CRE Crowdfunding Platforms Must Focus on Realistic Returns  National Real Estate InvestorCRE crowdfunding platforms need to focus on stringent underwriting and transparency to avoid misleading investors about potential returns. [...]

CFB Finance

Marketwired

  • Crowdfunding
  • Crowdfund
  • Peer to Peer Lending
  • FinTech
  • Reg A+
  • Reg CF
  • Crowdfunding USA

Press Release

Fintech World Beat

2020fintech.com' title='https://2020fintech.com/' target="_blank" class='rtw_url_link'>2020fintech.com 2019 Blockchain Mastermind Series 2020fintech.com' title='https://2020fintech.com/' target="_blank" class='rtw_url_link'>2020fintech.com #blockchain #digital #realestate #fintech ulation pic.twitter.com/wJC04nwJyl

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |