Delaying Crowdfunding to Save Crowdfunding?

By Jonathan Wilson, CrowdFunding Beat Guest Contributor, Corporate Counsel at Taylor English Duma LLP,

 

Berkeley Law Professor, Stephen Solomon, writing in the New York Times, suggests that the SEC’s “dawdling” with crowdfunding rules may be having the effect of “saving crowdfunding.”

sec (2)

There is a little truth to that. Issuing crowdfunding rules by the end of 2012, as was required by the JOBS Act, would have squelched efforts by the states to adopt their own crowdfunding rules. Instead, with the SEC deciding that it is not obliged to follow laws passed by the Congress and signed by the President, there has been more than enough political oxygen for the states to experiment with crowdfunding in the limited sphere permitted under the 1933 Act and SEC Rule 147 for intrastate offerings.

As I’ve written before, intrastate crowdfunding has created opportunities for small, locally-focused financings, largely involving real estate. Real estate projects satisfy the 80% of assets test under Rule 147 and generally have the kind of local interest needed so that 100% of the investors involved will be resident in the state.

But if the SEC’s refusal to follow the law by issuing regulations has saved crowdfunding, it’s more a matter of “bombing the village in order to save it.”

The SEC’s worries about fraud in crowdfunding appear to be a knee-jerk reaction to change, more justified in theory than in practice. The SEC’s solution to the fraud problem, proposing that most crowdfund issuers obtain and disclose audited financial statements would do little to eliminate fraud and would make most crowdfund offerings prohibitively expensive.

(If you are truly a fraudster, and wanted to bilk investors through crowdfunding, you could create a new entity, obtain audited financials (your de novo startup would have no historical financial results to audit) and still make off with the proceeds of your crowdfund offering.

If the SEC really wants to save crowdfunding it would be better served by listening to practitioners involved in raising capital for small business and to adopt rules that are more carefully calculated to work in the real world.

Jonathan B. Wilson is a corporate partner at Taylor English Duma and represents small and growing businesses in securities and financial matters. He blogs often atwww.emerginglawblog.com (Cross posted)

Written by
Jonathan Wilson

Jonathan Wilson Corporate Counsel at Taylor English Duma LLP,

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

HEADLINE NEWS

More Indiana teachers turn to crowdfunding to purchase classroom supplies  FOX 59 IndianapolisINDIANAPOLIS, Ind. - The average teacher spends more than $400 of their own money each year on school supplies. That's why more and more teachers are ... [...]

Crowdfunding your Product on Kickstarter or Indigogo: The Pros and Cons  China Law BlogThe Quality Inspection Blog did a really good post, entitled Pros and Cons of Crowdfunding (Kickstarter/Indiegogo) for Startups, explaining (yeah, you. [...]

PieShell, a Crowdfunding Platform for Food Innovation, is Shutting Down  The SpoonFood crowdfunding site PieShell is shutting down. The news was shared publicly today by company CEO and founder Cheryl Clements via an open letter on ... [...]

Iran bans non-official crowdfunding appeals after deadly flash floods  Euronews EnglishAuthorities said on Monday that they have closed 60 crowdfunding campaigns, mostly set up by celebrities, and that donations can only be made through official ... [...]

misterb&b hits the equity crowdfunding trail to expand into hotels  TechCrunchHomosexuality is illegal in a third of the counties on this planet; in eight countries it is punishable by death. In the febrile atmosphere of today's politics, ... [...]

Only 2 days remaining for CHUWI AeroBook crowdfunding campaign  Gizchina.comCHUWI's laptops are always bringing to the table extreme price/performance ratio and the new CHUWI AeroBook is no different. [...]

Game studio behind ‘Myst’ launches crowdfunding campaign for VR-enabled adventure ‘Firmament’  GeekWireCyan, the Spokane, Wash-based studio behind the Myst franchise and its spiritual successor, Obduction, began a new crowdfunding campaign today for their ... [...]

PrepayWay – A Swiss FinTech Holding Announces Start of Equity Crowdfunding Campaign  NullTXMarch 21st, 2019, Switzerland – People from different parts of the globe have an opportunity to contribute to the equity of the Swiss-Estonian startup using ... [...]

LEGO’s first crowdfunding experiment: FORMA 81000 Koi Model Super Box [Review]  The Brothers BrickLEGO FORMA is the company's first foray into crowdfunding. It is described as an “experience designed for adults looking for a fun and engaging way to ... [...]

OddFellows Kicks off Equity Crowdfunding Campaign - Restaurant News  QSR magazineIn keeping with their humorous and nostalgic positioning, in tandem with the campaign OddFellows has launched a cheeky hotline of 1-866-4ICE-CREAM. [...]

CFB Finance

Marketwired

  • Crowdfunding
  • Crowdfund
  • Peer to Peer Lending
  • FinTech
  • Reg A+
  • Reg CF
  • Crowdfunding USA

Press Release

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |