Unfair Manipulation in Crowdfunding Campaigns

CFB News Wire, Valencia, Spain — — 06/03/2014 — Joaquin Vila-Belda, PhD, and CEO of LifeKeeper talks about the company’s experience in crowdfunding and presents a preliminary analysis explaining the initiative to promote a forum called “Crowdfunding: Improving fair play.”

A few days ago, LifeKeeper launched a crowdfunding campaign on a well-known platform. The goal was to find backers for the first personal mobile device that can help prevent myocardial infarction and stroke.

However, after the first days of the campaign, the results were poor. For LifeKeeper, it was surprising to see such lack of response to a campaign with such an important goal – “combating the most common cause of death in the world” – even though it offers discounts of up to 40% to its backers. The crowdfunding campaign can be found at http://bit.ly/1mu4N68.

Consulted experts have expressed that the team behind the project clearly has a very strong professional background, and the purpose and motivation of the project are clear and easy to understand.

Before concluding on this issue, an analysis of what successful campaigns were doing was carried out.

first-img (1)

First, a sample of campaigns with different subjects was selected, including some on technology applied to healthcare.

After the aforementioned analysis, an apparent common factor for obtaining success is the originators’ ability to manipulate results by providing funds at key moments. This created a feeling of success, and, more importantly, raised them in the rankings used by the crowdfunding platform, such that their campaigns appear in the best positions and in publicity campaigns of the platform itself.

A specific case was followed in which a campaign had collected more than a million dollars, even though in the platform’s forum and in the press it was argued that the proposed device is not really useful for measuring calorie intake as promised (*).

But how is this possible?

In the cases studied, the procedure used is as follows:

– The funding goal for the campaign is set low, for example, $50,000.

– On the first day of the campaign, friends, acquaintances, and so on make contributions. Also, the originator of the campaign provides his or her own funds via anonymous or virtual user accounts, such as, $30,000; bringing the total to more than the campaign goal.

– This gives it an excellent ranking on the platform, placing the campaign on the website homepage.

– The media reports this extraordinary (but manipulated) early success.

– This has a knock-on effect: people are attracted to success, and the contributions of real backers multiply.

– Having passed the campaign goal, the platform begins to pay out the money.

– These real earnings are used to keep the campaign popular with more fictitious contributions.

In the cases that were analyzed, the amount of money used for manipulation was as much as 10% to 30% of the funds apparently raised. In the case of the device for measuring calorie intake, an initial support of $30,000 led to contributions which appear to top a million dollars. It is hard to know what the real investment by backers was, but in the mentioned case, signs of manipulation appear until the last three days of the campaign.

Consequently, LifeKeeper decided to promote a LinkedIn forum called “Crowdfunding: Improving fair play”, with the goal of finding answers to the following questions: Is it possible that backers are being so badly cheated? Is this abuse frequent or infrequent? How can this be avoided?

The forum is open to anyone interested, and can be found here: http://linkd.in/1pxjla5

Contacts:

General Inquiries: Marc Martin info(at)lifekeeper(dot)pro
Website: http://www.lifekeeper.pro
http://www.linkedin.com/in/jvilabelda

(*) Citation

http://pando.com/2014/03/20/on-indiegogo-a-miracle-health-device-raises-730k-and-a-whole-load-of-red-flags/

http://pando.com/2014/03/31/as-more-experts-dispute-gobes-bullshit-medical-claims-indiegogo-still-refuses-to-pull-its-near-1m-campaign/

Tags: , , , ,

HEADLINE NEWS

Crowdfunding deadline for community kitchen nears  The Daily TelegramADRIAN — The organizers of a community makerspace kitchen project have raised $35000 toward the $50000 goal of receiving matching funds from the ... [...]

Crowdfunding guide helps districts develop safe, effective practices  Education DiveChiefs for Change has released a new guide to help schools and districts use crowdfunding effectively, safely, and equitably, and to develop policies concerning ... [...]

Crowdfunding underway to re-purpose part of Bailey Park into dog-friendly area  WWMT-TVA crowdfunding initiative to raise a goal of $30000 is underway in Battle Creek in an effort to re-purpose a portion of Bailey Park into a new dog park, according ... [...]

Great Idea But No Capital? How To Launch A Business Through Crowdfunding  ForbesNoëlle Santos launched a viral crowdfunding campaign to open The Lit. Bar, a wine bar/bookstore in the Bronx. She shares her advice for crowdfunding a ... [...]

School Districts Are Banning Teachers From Using DonorsChoose  Education WeekAs teacher-led crowdfunding grows ever more popular, school leaders are starting to voice concerns. [...]

Insurance Giant AXA XL Launches Security Token and Crowdfunding Insurance Service  CointelegraphNews. Insurance giant AXA XL and insurance technology startup Assurely have jointly launched a new insurance product covering equity crowdfunding and ... [...]

MP to tap crowdfunding to finance campaign  The HinduN.K. Premachandran, the UDF candidate and sitting MP of Kollam, is all set to launch a crowdfunding drive to finance his election campaign.The facility to ... [...]

Currently Crowdfunding: A Smart Teapot, a Home Cheesemaker, and More  Core77.comNavigating the world of crowdfunding can be overwhelming, to put it lightly. Which projects are worth backing? Where's the filter to weed out the hundreds of ... [...]

Local businesses try crowdfunding to help expand, recover  The Register-GuardWhen Kevin Barrett fell from a ladder while constructing his distillery in Springfield, breaking six ribs, shattering his clavicle and puncturing his lung, it was his ... [...]

Healing Teddies seeks public embrace in crowdfunding campaign  The Jerusalem PostOnly weeks before her death, Ilana gave her mother a teddy bear, unaware of what this small gift would lead to. [...]

CFB Finance

Marketwired

  • Crowdfunding
  • Crowdfund
  • Peer to Peer Lending
  • FinTech
  • Reg A+
  • Reg CF
  • Crowdfunding USA

Press Release

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |