Tread carefully on equity crowdfunding

State bill has both advantages and pitfalls.

To cut down on fraud during the Great Depression, Washington banned private companies from soliciting investments from the general public. Since then, only relatively wealthy people — those who qualify as “accredited investors” by virtue of income or assets — have been able to buy shares of companies not listed on a public stock exchange.

The passage in early 2012 of the federal JOBS Act — short for Jumpstart Our Business Startups — was intended to change that. Among other things, the JOBS Act embraced “crowdfunding” as a way for privately held companies, usually start-ups, to raise money from ordinary investors through online fundraising campaigns.

More than 16 months after President Barack Obama signed the JOBS Act, the federal Securities and Exchange Commission is still writing the rules of the game. The reasons for the delay are more complex than a federal agency stiff-arming the president and Congress.

Crowdfunding in the Internet era has largely been a province of artists, causes and special projects that don’t come with an expectation of profit. You might get an awesome T-shirt or a front-row ticket out of your crowdfunding investment, as well as some warm feelings about your involvement, but not a lot more.

That changed with the advent of “equity crowdfunding,” through which small companies may sell small pieces of their company in return for the cash needed to move it from start-up to success. The expectations for investors are very different: Instead of a T-shirt, they look for a return on investment.

The concept was embraced by the JOBS Act, within certain investment limits, but it ran head-long into the SEC’s historic concern about society inventing new ways to swindle grandmothers and other unsuspecting investors.

So, while most of the nation waits for the SEC rules, two states have moved ahead with crowdfunding on their own. Georgia and Kansas have taken the plunge; North Carolina and Washington state are considering similar state-based platforms.

Joining the march, three Wisconsin legislators said this month they will introduce a bill to rewrite Wisconsin’s securities law to allow equity crowdfunding. To get a crowdfunding exemption under the Wisconsin proposal, a company would need to:

■ Be a Wisconsin business selling stock to state investors.

■ Not raise more than $1 million, or $2 million if the company issuing stock is willing to be audited and make the audit available to investors.

■ Not sell more than $5,000 in stock to anyone who is not an accredited investor. Accredited investors have to earn more than $100,000 per year, or $150,000 for married couples, or have a net worth of $750,000 or more. That’s a different standard than set by the SEC.

■ Issue the stock through an Internet site registered with the state Department of Financial Institutions; file disclosure statements; and share those disclosure documents with investors.

■ Have stock payments held in escrow by a Wisconsin bank.

■ Not have offered or sold other stock through the exemption in the past year.

The advantages of the state bill begin with the democratizing of equity investments in private companies. Mom and Pop could invest in mom-and-pop businesses. It also brings money off the sidelines for deals too small or early for angel and venture capitalists to consider. There’s also considerably less regulatory burden on companies that would otherwise need to pursue a private offering exemption under existing federal law. It could become a “farm system” for angel and venture capitalists to keep an eye on emerging companies.

There are some potential pitfalls, as well. The Depression-era mentality about protecting investors from themselves wasn’t entirely Rooseveltian paternalism. People can and do fall victim to fraud — even in public markets.

A proliferation of state rules could create a patchwork quilt of laws that might hamper commerce rather than encourage it. Can a global portal like the Internet truly screen out non-Wisconsin investors if they’re determined to get around it? Upstream investors might shun buying out crowdfunded deals if the list of previous investors is too hard to unravel, which could leave those initial investors stranded.

Perhaps the biggest danger is adverse selection. If the best deals are attracting experienced money from venture capitalists or angel groups, does that mean crowdfunding investors are left to pick from a less desirable pool? Are they seeing second-tier deals?

If so, the gold-rush mentality of crowdfunding could give way to disappointment among an entire class of investors who aren’t accustomed to the stark reality that many start-ups fail, even when backed with institutional money.

The SEC may be dragging its feet, but Wisconsin should carefully examine all sides of crowdfunding before running too far ahead.

[Source: Tom Still @ JSOnline]

http://www.jsonline.com/business/tread-carefully-on-equity-crowdfunding-b9981502z1-220941091.html

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

HEADLINE NEWS

U.S. News & World ReportNo Cash for Hate, Say Mainstream Crowdfunding FirmsU.S. News & World ReportThe block on mainstream crowdfunding is just the latest blow to far-right activists operating online. In the last 24 hours, neo-Nazi website the Daily Stormer had its domain regi [...]

Global Crowdfunding Market 2017-2021PR Newswire (press release)Global Crowdfunding Market 2017-2021, has been prepared based on an in-depth market analysis with inputs from industry experts. The report covers the market landscape and its growth prospects over the coming years. The rep [...]

Crain's Cleveland Business'Smaller' gifts can go long way for Clinic's crowdfunding platformCrain's Cleveland BusinessFor an institution accustomed to securing multimillion-dollar donations, Cleveland Clinic's latest fundraising effort has some relatively [...]

NewshubWoman born without vagina crowdfunding surgeryNewshubThe family of a woman born without a vagina has started a crowdfunding campaign to receive reconstructive surgery. Kaylee Moats, from Arizona, lives with Mayer Rokitansky Küster Hauser syndrome (MRKH) meaning she has no cervi [...]

ForbesWhat Works In Equity Crowdfunding -- Insights From ResearchForbesAs we have recently celebrated the fourth anniversary of the signing of the JOBS Act into law, it is a good time to take stock of the effect that the legislature had on equity crowdfunding in the United States. It [...]

Technical.ly BaltimoreArbit took to crowdfunding to seek out investorsTechnical.ly BaltimoreThe Baltimore-based social polling company is seeking to raise a maximum of $425,000 through equity crowdfunding, a funding instrument that was first officially made available last year with re [...]

ForbesMoney Makes Small Businesses Go Round: Ensuring Access For AllForbesIn 2008, a new form of financing — rewards-based crowdfunding — premiered. With money raised on crowdfunding platforms like Indiegogo and Kickstarter, startups and companies with a new product idea connect direc [...]

Baltimore Business JournalCrowdfunding initiative for women-owned startups comes to MarylandBaltimore Business JournaliFundWomen, a crowdfunding platform dedicated to helping women-led businesses find support, is launching in Maryland in partnership with the incubator Betamore, PNC Ba [...]

CNETKickstarter alternatives: Choosing a crowdfunding platformCNETCrowdfunding, a compelling way to raise funds and generate buzz for a new entrepreneurial endeavor, is almost synonymous with Kickstarter. While Kickstarter is a major platform, several other crowdfunding sites are wort [...]

SiliconBeatPayPal, crowdfunding sites cut off white supremacists, hate groupsSiliconBeatPayPal and some crowdfunding sites have joined other tech companies in cutting off hate groups after the deadly white supremacist rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, over the weekend. The Southern [...]

CFB Finance

Marketwired

  • Crowdfunding
  • Crowdfund
  • Peer to Peer Lending
  • FinTech
  • Reg A+
  • Reg CF
  • Crowdfunding USA

Press Release

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |