Just another day…..


By Steve Cinelli , CrowdFund Beat Sr. Editor, @stevecinelli

Quite the events in the marketplace finance sector over the last week.   Originally icons, now fallen stars, Lending Club (LC), OnDeck Capital (ONDK) and Prosper (PSPR) are exhibiting possible growing pains or even further symptoms of a more serious condition, namely questionable business models. It seemed only yesterday that firms such as Goldman Sachs and execs like Jamie Dimon expressed anxiety about the challenges to the conventional banking business that these new models would bring on.  Deal and profit erosion was the concern as these nascent yet compelling platforms were accomplishing what the banking industry couldn’t, wouldn’t or even shouldn’t do, but impact they will.   With recent earnings releases, and notable events, such as the departure of thought-leader, Renaud Laplanche and layoffs at Prosper, there are now those that suggest the “sky is falling” and the marketplace finance industry, let alone the basic model, is suspect.

Both before and after the IPOs of ONDK and LC, I scribed a few pieces that stated that, even with the accoutrements of a technology spin, these were still finance businesses, and should be accorded, rather measured, on the same basis of their banking brethren.   Simply, they generate revenues for facilitating finance, on balance sheet or off, regardless whether there is “pixie dust” applied through algorithmic analysis and machine learning.  Heck, when I started my banking career with Bank of America a few decades ago, there was already the application of formulaic credit scoring, objectively and agnostically, for consumer loans.  So now we use a computer to do the scoring.  BFD.  And don’t you think that WFB and BAC and Capital One have methods of assess credit quality in an expeditious fashion. I do believe their tech budgets for such things are not impecunious.

In many ways, I would love to advance the notion that we are seeing a redux of the dot com / dot bomb days, where nosebleed values were placed on models only because they were different, independent of having a legitimate revenue model and path to financial sustainability.  The current “originate and sell” methods of the marketplace platforms is highly questionable, as they can generate revenues only by doing more deals, as there is no recurrent revenue stream within their activities.  Does this bode ominously for sub-prime product being advanced to sustain growth, like the mortgage banking industry demonstrated in the mid-2000’s?  There is already waning appetite for the product, i.e., consumer and SME loans, being sold to the investment community.   Delinquencies are rising, losses too, and loan sale premiums are eroding.  Is the party over?  Not in the least.  But yes, a reboot is coming upon us.

Lending, as a subset of finance, is an information business.   Users of capital supply providers of capital information in an iterative fashion, hoping to become resolute on a financing decision.  If the analysis proves out, the loan is made, the anticipated performance will follow.  But as we know, this is not a riskless proposition, thus safeguards and structures need be established.  The challenge in the new money lending business, i.e., marketplace finance, is whether these platforms can actually do what they do not only efficiently, but profitably.  When you dissect the origination costs, servicing, technology, underwriting and so on, the unit economic model of the platforms is suspect. Even beyond the aforementioned lending platforms, there are now close to 2000 online finance platforms, whether doing consumer, small business, or real estate lending, in addition to originating equity financing for emerging businesses.   Technology has enabled many industries to execute profitably in more acute and granular levels, and that has been the hope and dream of crowdfunding.  But technology in this space is the art, while finance still remains the science, and how finance companies make money, in the analog world is worth revisiting.  Intermediation can be efficient, but is there any wonder that some of these platforms now understand the value of balance sheets and recurrent income?  Being dismissive of the conventional fractional reserve, balance sheet model may be premature.   Do anticipate that the new will see merit in the old, as the old benefits from the new.   The sky is not falling.  Maybe a stubbed toe, and a time of reflection?  The future is still quite bright, but it will require reassessment of both models and definitely some of the current players.








Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,


MarketWatchWhy a crowdfunding site is giving out $10000 scholarshipsMarketWatchCrowdfunding site GoFundMe announced Thursday that it will award $10,000 to 10 students with pages on their site that fundraise for education. The award is part of a contest the site held throughout Septemb [...]

BloombergCouples Desperate For Children Turn to Crowdfunding FertilityBloombergCrowdfunding has become a popular mechanism for many couples who can't afford the high costs of IVF, or adoption and surrogacy. “It's not an easy thing to share publicly,” says Crystal Barrett, 33 [...]

Crowdfund InsiderBrief: GoFundMe Presents $100000 in College Scholarships to 10 StudentsCrowdfund InsiderTo qualify for the scholarships, each student had to create a crowdfunding campaign on GoFundMe, shared stories about the obstacles they had overcome in pursuing their education, h [...]

Huffington PostReal Estate Crowdfunding's Pathway of ChangeHuffington Post“Crowdfunding is just the Internet,” stated Attorney Mark Roderick as he opened last month's RealCap Chicago. RealCap is an annual conference that joins crowdfunding leaders and innovators to propel th [...]

Smart From The Start: 3 Ways To Properly Establish Your Business When CrowdfundingCBS LocalConsequently, burgeoning entrepreneurs have turned to crowdfunding platforms to get the seed money they need to get business ideas off the ground. However, seeing as 98 percent of crowdfunding p [...]

Crowdfund InsiderTitle III Crowdfunding Might Not Be What Many ExpectedCrowdfund InsiderI have been immersed in the equity crowdfunding industry since late 2015 and have tried to collect as many different perspectives on the industry from as many experts as possible. And while it is h [...]

The RegisterHardware ain't hard, money is: Crowdfunding, bootstraps and startupsThe RegisterHmm, I think we call this bootstrapping in IT, or in our case crowdfunding. Raise enough money to get the first shippable product and ship it. (I did once work on a "big" defence [...]

Crowdfund InsiderSEC Schedules Open Meeting on Rules 147 & 504 Impacting Intrastate CrowdfundingCrowdfund InsiderMary Jo White October 30 2015 The SEC has scheduled a meeting to consider proposed amendments related to Rules 147 and 504 – securities regulations that impact intrasta [...]

ExtremeTechNew crowdfunding project promises an ATX motherboard for IBM's Power8ExtremeTechWe don't cover many crowdfunding projects at ExtremeTech, because most of the pitches we get are frankly terrible. While we can't make any promises about any crowdfunding project [...]

CoinTelegraphCrowdfunding vs. ICO: Experts Question Legitimacy and Guarantees of Initial Coin OfferingsCoinTelegraphOne major difference exists between traditional crowdfunding methods and ICO, and that is market value. When a product is introduced on crowdfunding platforms like Indie [...]

CFB Finance

Press Release

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |