Equity Crowdfunding But Whose Crowd Is It?

 Contributing Editor,

This article with an Equity crowdfunding headline got me thinking.

First equity crowdfunding deal in Australia for 2016 raises more than $675,000

Picture Courtesy of Crowdsourcing

To an entity getting funded to the tune of $675,000 is a great achievement. For a platform to facilitate this is also a great achievement. Well done!

However the phrase “With three days still remaining, it has raised $675,000 from 15 wholesale investors” shouldn’t be the substance for a headline like “First equity crowdfunding deal in Australia for 2016 raises more than $675,000”.

Even before the words equity crowdfunding evolved an entity could always receive $675,000 from 15 wholesale investors.

There has never been anything legal stopping that. Equity crowdfunding, as I see it,  is about gathering and communicating with people that are somehow related or connected now or in the future to an entity and are effectively the entities crowd. And … they are not all “smart investors” as smart investors are normally orientated towards the investment by more traditional means rather than having been gathered by the entity for this individual raise!

This happens a lot on Real Estate Equity Crowdfunding platforms. The investors are gathered off-line and then published online. Problem with that is you never actually know if the platform, the intermediary, another platform or another intermediary actually “raised” the funds the platform is claiming.

15 wholesale investors and no other investors is someone else’s crowd. They certainly aren’t the entities crowd.

After over 300 equity crowdfunding raises I found the following statistics were fairly true. Gather a crowd of 620 around your entity, of those 207 will read your offer document and 20 will invest. From your crowd. Yes there will be 2 or 3 sophisticated or professional investors … but 15!

Thats someone else’s crowd.

As you glance around platforms in Australasia whether it be Equitise, Snowball orVenturecrowd there are more and more hybrid raises being pitched. Meaning raises where only part of the raise is sought on the platform. In other words it is someone else raise.

The often touted “we are democratising investing” is getting lost as platforms move their focus away from early stage startups and SME’s not yet ready for the “smart money” towards raises that are well and truly pitched at the smart money.

The Australian Equity Crowdfunding Legislation on its way through parliament at the moment will just reinforce this trend. Deals for “smart investors” run by licensed operators that will use retail investors to top up deals. On its own there is nothing wrong with that but all the hype has been around supporting small business and job creation. That wont happen the way things are going because in reality the type of pitches we are seeing probably would have been funded by the “smart money” any way.

If you read a previous post of mine on the legitimisation of friends and family investment you will see the two frames of equity crowdfunding.

  1. The entities crowd. Predominantly retail, friends and family, passionate supporters with a few high net worths (Title III in the U.S.)
  2. The regulators licensed platform’s crowd. Predominantly “smart money” with a few retail investors welcomed in to “top up” (Title II and Reg D in the U.S.) .

The Australian Small Business Minister has pitched it as 1. above (where job creation is) but delivered 2. above. This mismatch is why there has been negative criticism. Helping small business and creating jobs speeches go down well with the electorate but this is not going to happen with the proposed Australian Equity Crowdfunding Legislation.

Long term these licensed intermediaries, as agents of the state because they are trusted to manage the transactions with integrity and fairness will be superseded by peer to peer blockchain facilitated structures. Then true intelligent investor aggregation and embedded trust factors will be more relevant than gatekeepers, their own crowds and the regulator.


But that’s just my opinion… what do you think?

About the Author: Paul Niederer is the COO at Crowdsourcing Week, a global forum to present collaborative solutions for the 21st century. Crowdsourcing Week Global annually gathers forward-thinking executives, entrepreneurs and leaders to learn the disruptive applications, opportunities and implications of the Crowd Economy across industries.


Unlock The Power of Your Crowd

How can the crowd drive growth, innovation and efficiency for your organization? Join me at the fourth annual Crowdsourcing Week Global for an unparalleled look at the how the crowd economy is fundamentally changing business practices across all industries.

Virgin describes it as “Fascinating talks… on everything from smart cities to the sharing economy.” Learn from 60+ global experts blazing the path, who will share the crowd technologies, trends, best-practices, and market opportunities that are driving massive transformation and innovation—and how to apply it within your organization.


Paul Niederer is one of world’s leading authorities in equity based crowdfunding investments and raisings and constructing collaborative funding solutions. He has personally been involved in over $75 million of transactions with 90 different companies seeking capital.

With the intense interest worldwide in EquityCrowdfunding Platforms, and Collaborative Funding Platforms Paul is involved in consulting to a number of parties on how to structure their funding portals, processes and regulations to have successful raises with a fair deal for investors and stakeholders.

He regularly presents seminars on on a number of topics including Collaborative Funding,  Crowdfunding in 2020, Investor Crowdfunding: How to run and manage your own platform compliantly and successfully, The Democratization of Capital – Why it is happening now and how to handle it and Executive and Management Briefings on Crowdfunding.

Paul has spoked at a number of events worldwide including the annual Crowdfunding Bootcamp in Las Vegas, the Crowdfunding Asia Summit in Singapore, INSME Academy’s “How Small Businesses Can Embrace Crowdfunding for Success!”, the WASME 19th International Conference on SMEs in Durban, the Crowdfund Investing Innovation Forum in Orlando with the topic “Fraud and the Crowd” and an International Business Angels Event in Amsterdam.

His experience is with both accredited and unaccredited investor raises. While many jurisdictions have platforms running with only accredited investor raises Paul has had extensive experience in managing both accredited and unaccredited raises with both investor types often in the same raise. Internationally he is known as “Mr Governance” due to the fraud free reign he managed while day CEO of ASSOB, the world’s oldest equity crowdfunding platform. He as spoken in minimising fraud in equity based crowdfunding transactions a number of times.

Paul lives south of Brisbane on Australia’s eastern coast and relishes the opportunity to discuss peer to peer finance developments and any moves towards the democratisation of capital.


Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,


How Crowdfunding Has Changed the Startup GameSingularity HubCrowdfunding has become a multi-billion-dollar industry, funneling millions of dollars into thousands of projects. Technology in particular is one of the leading categories on popular fundraising platforms like Kickstarter an [...]

The GuardianCrowdfunding: the new buzzword for academics needing research moneyThe GuardianArchaeologist Dr David Petts, from Durham University, has also used crowdfunding, raising almost £25,000 to fund a project on Lindisfarne, off the Northumberland coast. The dig, in June, led to [...]

Airbitz, BitPay, and Wefunder leverage bitcoin and new US ...Brave New CoinEquity crowdfunding platform, Wefunder, recently started accepting bitcoin. On the same day, popular bitcoin mobile wallet provider Airbitz announced the ...Wefunder Launches 10 New Regulation Crowdfunding Offe [...]

CNNMoneyDorothy's fading red slippers saved by $300000 in crowdfundingCNNMoneyThe ruby red slippers worn by Judy Garland in the beloved 1939 film "The Wizard of Oz" are set to undergo a major conservation effort following a successful crowdfunding campaign. The Smithson [...]

Raise Money for Personal Bills on Crowdfunding SitesKiplinger Personal FinanceWhile crowdfunding is often associated with business start-ups, many people are finding it a fruitful way to raise money for personal needs. Sites such as YouCaring, GoGetFunding, GoFundMe and GiveForward ha [...]

Crowdfund InsiderReport: Title II Crowdfunding Data on Three Year Anniversary Tops $1.47 BillionCrowdfund InsiderFifty Dollars Money Grant Crowdnetic has published its annual Crowdwatch report on Title II investment crowdfunding as enacted under the JOBS Act of 2012. Title II, or Reg [...]

How The Fix Crowdfunding Act Continues To Help Improve The Success Rates Of Small BusinessesCBS LocalIn July of this year, Republican Patrick McHenry from North Carolina spearheaded two important bills. Both passed through the House in a landslide vote as part of The Fix Crowdfunding [...]

BloombergCouples Desperate For Children Turn to Crowdfunding FertilityBloombergCrowdfunding has become a popular mechanism for many couples who can't afford the high costs of IVF, or adoption and surrogacy. “It's not an easy thing to share publicly,” says Crystal Barrett, 33 [...]

City turns to crowd funding to help replace boardwalk over Flint RiverMLive.comFLUSHING, MI -- The city of Flushing has opened a crowdfunding campaign to replace a wooden boardwalk over the Flint River. The goal is to raise $50,000 in 60 days on Patronicity, a crowdfunding website, to [...]

AZCentral.comTiny companies lure investors under Arizona crowdfunding lawAZCentral.comInvestors who make bets under the state's one-year-old crowdfunding law certainly have the potential to get in on the ground floor, but they must be patient and might not receive any returns. Th [...]

CFB Finance

Press Release

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |