As competitive moats shallow, many robo-advisors look to be acquired.

3c11fad

 

 

 

 

Ryan Caldbeck Ryan Caldbeck

Founder and CEO at CircleUp

Robo-advisors are here to stay. The question is, in what form?

Individual investors have flocked to robo-advisors, drawn to the low fees, market-indexed returns, automated tax loss harvesting, and ease of use they offer. The model is as effective, if not more effective, than those built by traditional private wealth management firms; all the while offered at a lower cost. So it’s not surprising to see some project the amount of assets invested through robo-platforms to grow more than ten-fold by 2020 and reach approximately $2 trillion worth of U.S. assets under management (AUM).

Clearly, robo-advisors are good for individual investors: just as online brokerages revolutionized stock trading for the masses 25 years ago, robo-advisors are doing the same for wealth management. But it’s not all rosy. Robo-advisors have a problem, and it’s a big one: the bedrock of their business, the algorithms that power users’ asset allocation, is a commodity.

download (25)

 

 

 

As valuable as the algorithms are to individual investors who lack the time or know-how to build and constantly rebalance a complex portfolio, the underlying algorithms are easy to reproduce. What this means is that there is no core asset to differentiate (and protect) the business from competitors.

Increasingly, senior leaders at independent robo-advisors are awakening to the realization that their businesses have shallow moats. While they’re attracting thousands of customers and billions of assets, their scale isn’t protecting them from the next robo-advisor platform (or service) that emerges with its own flavor of algorithm. That’s why many of these robo-advisors have enlisted investment bankers to help them find viable exit strategies – namely to be acquired. BlackRock’s acquisition of five-year-old FutureAdvisor last summer was likely just the beginning.

I’ve even heard that one robo-advisor plans to white-label its product — which often foreshadows a rapid slide to lower margins in any industry.

Moreover, the dozens of robo-advisors competing to grow AUM are now facing pressure from brokerage houses and wealth advisory firms that are developing their own algorithms in-house. Already, Schwab has launched Schwab Intelligent Portfolios, and Vanguard has launched its Personal Advisor Services. There’s no reason not to expect eTrade, Fidelity, Ameritrade and others to follow suit. (At an analyst presentation last Summer Schwab CEO Walter Bettinger predicted that within a few years all financial services firms will offer proprietary versions of online investment advice.)

It’s a crowded and undifferentiated space—and the odds of long-term survival of independent robo-advisors look small.

Contrast that with an online investment marketplace. As I’ve said before, marketplaces are the best business model. In a marketplace, the core asset is defensible because as the business adds participants—both buyers and sellers—the value of the platform increases for all participants. An investor using a robo advisor gains no added value from more investors using that platform; in a marketplace, however, the network effect means that the addition of more buyers and sellers adds value for all participants. This network effect creates a wide competitive moat, and, consequently, a defensible business model.

As large, well-established investment firms enter the robo-advisor market, investors will be hard pressed to find compelling reasons to switch from say a Fidelity, Schwab or Vanguard to an independent platform given the algorithm (and value proposition) is essentially the same.

Short of selling themselves – or their algorithms, which is one in the same – robo-advisors have few options to create a sustainable business. One thing they can do, however, is differentiate by diversifying their product portfolios. The availability of private equity investments, real estate and debt products, for example, would make a robo-advisor unique in this crowded space.

One avenue worth exploring is partnering with online platforms that provide alternative assets as a long-term strategy. Without product differentiation, however, already low margins will continue to erode for the robo-advisors that manage to survive.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

HEADLINE NEWS

Equity Crowdfunding: What Kinds of Businesses Are Being Funded?Motley FoolThe Jumpstart Our Business Startups Act -- aka, the JOBS Act -- went into effect last year, opening up the equity crowdfunding industry. In this clip from Industry Focus: Tech, Motley Fool tech analyst Dylan Lew [...]

Forbes7 Ways To Generate PR For Your Crowdfunding CampaignForbesAs a contributor to Forbes and the owner of a PR firm, I've seen thousands of pitches from companies using crowdfunding platforms like Kickstarter and Indiegogo. These founders are generally in a state of desperation [...]

Forbes4 Dirty Little Secrets Of Crowdfunding And Why You Should Still Do ItForbesI wasn't prepared for what would happen when I jumped into the murky crowdfunding waters. Before you end up splashed with cold water like I was, here are ...and more » [...]

Equity Crowdfunding and Venture Capital, More Friends than Foes ...Motley FoolIndiegogo's founder shares his thoughts on the trends shaping equity crowdfunding.and more » [...]

EntrepreneurHow to Launch a Successful Crowdfunding ProjectEntrepreneurThis is exactly what Andrew Thomas did. Thomas is the co-founder of Skybell, an interactive video doorbell for your smart home. Thomas went right into the heart of entrepreneurship when he became one of the top 10 [...]

Five garden crowdfunding projects to back this springThe Guardian (blog)Five garden crowdfunding projects to back this spring. From giving women at Yarl's Wood a place to garden, to transforming a Glasgow community's soft drinks habit, these projects are all seeking funds to [...]

Myrtle Beach Sun NewsThree Grand Strand area projects and their leaders who have tried crowdfundingMyrtle Beach Sun NewsKickstarter is just one player on the field of online crowdfunding platforms. Other companies with quirky names like Indiegogo, Fundable, GoFundMe, Patreon and many [...]

What Does the Future Hold for Equity Crowdfunding? -- The Motley ...Motley FoolThe equity crowdfunding market has just started to take off after last year's implementation of the JOBS Act. Here's what two pioneers in the space see in store for ...and more » [...]

RTCrowdfunding for police officer murdered in London attack exceeds early targetRTA crowdfunding initiative to raise money for family of the police officer killed during the London terrorist attack has received a massive amount of donations. TrendsUK Parliament terrorist attack. The a [...]

ChipInTop 6 Crowdfunding Trends for 2017ChipInThat influence was felt in the crowdfunding world as well through the many voice-controlled smart home systems and other devices that made waves. With voice user interfaces positioned as the next big thing in technology in the same vein as [...]

CFB Finance

Marketwired

  • Crowdfunding
  • Crowdfund
  • Peer to Peer Lending
  • FinTech
  • Reg A+
  • Reg CF
  • Crowdfunding USA

Press Release

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |