FTC Settles Crowdfunding Fraud Case

  CrowdFundBeat , Sr. contributing guest editor, partner in the corporate law department of Taylor English  LLP

The FTC announced last week its first settlement in a crowdfunding fraud case.

The FTC had accused Erik Chevalier of defrauding consumers in a Kickstarter crowdfunding campaign in which he sought to raise funds for a board game to be called “The Doom that Came to Atlantic City.”

Chevalier and his company, The Forking Path, launched their campaign for “The Doom That Came to Atlantic City” on Kickstarter in May 2012.  The game was based on a board that looked a lot like Monopoly, and required players to play the roles of villains in a post-apocalyptic version of Atlantic City.

Chevalier’s campaign looked to raise $35,000, with each $50 pledge receiving a copy of the to-be developed game.  Pledges of more money would provide extra awards.  After some initial excitement, the campaign raised more than its goal, eventually pulling in $122,874 from more than 1,200 funders.

But Chevalier and Forking Path never completed the game or fulfilled rewards to backers.  Chevalier eventually posted on Kickstarter in June 2013 that he was abandoning the effort, saying, “My hope now is to eventually refund everyone fully.”

The Federal Trade Commission (or “FTC”) under Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act has the authority to bring civil causes against defendants who engage in any “unfair or deceptive act or practice” in interstate commerce.

AAEAAQAAAAAAAAJBAAAAJGY0YzE4MGIxLTgyM2YtNGNkYy1hZWFiLWJhOWJkZjE4YTQ3OA

Kickstarter’s mandatory terms of fundraising projects requires promoters to either deliver promised rewards to funders or to refund pledges made.  The FTC claimed that Chevalier breached those terms when he announced that he was abandoning the effort without either delivering his promised rewards or providing backers a refund.

 

The FTC’s settlement, which follows its usual form, imposes a judgment of roughly $111,000 on Chevalier but suspends that judgment because of his inability to pay.  Instead, Chevalier is subject to a lifetime injunction from engaging in any misrepresentation in connection with a crowdfunding campaign.  If the FTC finds that Chevalier has violated the terms of the settlement (or has misrepresented his financial condition) the entire amount of the judgment becomes due and Chevalier is deemed to have admitted to all of the material claims in the FTC’s case.

Two lessons are important from this case.  The first, which should be obvious, is that standard prohibitions against fraud are in place and are enforceable in the crowdfunding context.  Promoters who don’t fulfill their promises in the crowdfunding context should expect the possibility of FTC anti-fraud enforcement.

The second is that the Chevalier case was a “rewards” crowdfunding campaign, not a crowdfunded offering of securities.  Backers were promised a copy of the game and other tangible rewards, not an equity stake in Chevalier’s business.  Opponents of securities-based crowdfunding have claimed that crowdfunding is dangerous because of the potential for fraud.  That potential exists, of course, but it is no more likely to occur in the context of a securities offering than it is in the context of a rewards offering.  Fraud, it is sad to say, finds root in every aspect of human endeavor.

The FTC’s Chevalier settlement, however, has little in it to guide future crowdfunding campaigns because Chevalier’s errors were so obvious and straightforward.  Chevalier breached his promises to his backers and admitted to that failure when he posted on Kickstarted that he was abandoning the effort but hoped to provide rewards in the future.  That this should be unacceptable should be clear to any future crowdfunding promoter

Jonathan-B-Wilson-

 

 

 

Jonathan B. Wilson is a partner in the corporate law department of Taylor English Duma where he represents growing companies in finance, securities and technology matters. He can be reached at jwilson@taylorenglish.com.

 

Tags: , , , , ,

HEADLINE NEWS

ForbesTitle III Crowdfunding For Real, Part IIForbesTitle III of the JOBS Act went into effect last year, and many entrepreneurs and small businesses are curious about if it works and how. I had the pleasure of interviewing several companies that have gone through “equity crowdfunding [...]

EntrepreneurThis Crowdfunding Category Will Blow Up in 2017, Says the CEO of ...EntrepreneurDavid Mandelbrot believes these kinds of products will be big on the crowdfunding platform this year. He also shares his tips for successful fundraising.and more » [...]

ABC OnlineCrowdfunding raises $50000 for new Australia Day campaign with girls in hijabsThe GuardianA picture of two girls wearing hijabs was taken at a 2016 Australia Day event in Docklands. The photograph was used in a 2017 Australia Day billboard which included rolling images of pe [...]

EntrepreneurCan Equity Crowdfunding Be Fixed?EntrepreneurWith the adoption last year of the Regulation Crowdfunding (Reg CF) exemptions by the Securities and Exchange Commissionprivate companies can now raise capital from all 230 million American adults. Until now, businesses have bee [...]

Business InsiderLondon startup Pact Coffee moved out of its office after failing to raise a £1 million crowdfunding roundBusiness InsiderPact Coffee's move comes after the startup failed to hit a £1 million crowdfunding target last March. The Crowdcube campaign was terminated ear [...]

Phys.OrgCrowdfunding expands innovation financing to underserved regionsPhys.OrgThe study found that crowdfunding in a region, and in particular successful technology campaigns, appeared to cause an increase in venture capital funding in the region. This occurs as venture capitalists [...]

Funerals paid for by crowdfunding are on the riseBBC NewsCharles Wells, chief operations officer for JustGiving, said: "Thinking about the costs of a funeral is the last thing a grieving family wants to do but with the cost of funerals rising JustGiving has seen increasing number [...]

Crowdfund InsiderBeatStars & Play Impossible Set to Close Successful Equity ...Crowdfund InsiderBeatStars and Play Impossible are set to close their crowdfunding campaigns through Indiegogo and MicroVentures' equity crowdfunding platform. The two init.and more » [...]

Telegraph.co.ukWellesley to freeze crowdfunding campaign as it courts City investorsTelegraph.co.ukPeer-to-peer property lender Wellesley is suspending its crowd-funding efforts as it courts City investors to help fund its expansion. Wellesley is set to pause its campaign that asked s [...]

Road to VRVive Strap Accessory with Flip-up Visor and PSVR-style Comfort Passes Crowdfunding GoalRoad to VRSynergyWiz says they're wrapping up the design phase of the head-mount and have taken to Kickstarter to crowdfund the remaining development, charging $85 for each rEvolve he [...]

CFB Finance

Marketwired

  • Crowdfunding
  • Crowdfund
  • Peer to Peer Lending
  • FinTech
  • Reg A+
  • Reg CF
  • Crowdfunding USA

Press Release

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |