Lending Club IPO Packs More than the Usual Legal Drama


18dfbc8[Editor’s Note: This is a guest post by Brian Korn. He is the Founder and Co-Head of Crowdfunding and Peer-to-Peer Lending at Pepper Hamilton LLP. Brian has become one of the leading legal experts in the country on p2p lending and he is a regular speaker at industry conferences. We asked him to write about the Lending Club IPO from a legal perspective, commenting on some of the lesser known issues, including whether Lending Club will become available to investors in all 50 states post-IPO.]

The upcoming initial public offering of LendingClub Corporation will be a true “coming of age” event in the peer-to-peer lending industry.  Though Lending Club and its chief rival, Prosper Marketplace, have been in business for about eight years, the industry has seen tremendous momentum in the past two years.  Lending Club passed $5 billion in loans originated in June and Prosper crossed $2 billion just last week.

Industry executives often describe the potential of the industry as being vast and virtually limitless.  “We are in the first inning,” Ron Suber, President of Prosper often says.

Lending Club and Prosper originate loans through a funding bank, purchase the loans and then either sell whole loans to institutions or issue “borrower payment dependent notes” (or member payment dependent notes depending on the platform) to the investing public.  But because the notes are not listed on a national securities exchange such as NYSE or Nasdaq, Lending Club and Prosper must apply for permission from each state in which it wants to distribute notes.  About 20 states have refused to allow sales of notes, meaning investors in those states cannot invest in payment-dependent notes.  Some very large states are included on this list – Texas, Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Ohio to name a few.

Several emerging peer-to-peer platforms such as Peerform and Patch of Land sell payment-dependent notes to accredited investors in “private placements” that are exempt from SEC registration under Rule 506 of the Securities Act of 1933 (also known as Regulation D).  By offering notes to accredited investors, sales can be made in all states without state approval.  This concept is known as “federal preemption.”

Preemption for Payment-Dependent Notes?

Federal preemption applies, in addition to Rule 506, to securities listed on a national securities exchange or any securities issued by the same issuer that are “pari passu” or senior to listed securities.  So when General Electric sells bonds, they are preempted from state securities laws (also known as “blue sky laws”) because those securities are senior to GE common stock.  When Lending Club lists common stock on the NYSE in connection with its upcoming IPO, payment-dependent notes will also be preempted, opening the door to sales to the public in all 50 states and DC.  Notes are debt instruments of the company and under the rules of corporate liquidation, debt is senior to equity.

Some states have quietly voiced concern over the prospect of preemption for payment-dependent notes, likely because such milestone will remove state authority to regulate peer-to-peer note offerings in the state.  States that currently do not allow payment-dependent notes to be sold may attempt to continue to restrict sales following the IPO.  State legal arguments are that since no liquidation of Lending Club would have a payment-dependent noteholder paid ahead of a common stockholder, how can notes tied to a single loan with no recourse to any other assets of the company be senior to common stock, which has an ultimate liquidation claim to the assets of the company?

States rarely get involved in fighting preemption issues, but payment-dependent notes represent a new battlefront.  State securities regulators are fighting preemption (and ultimate disintermediation) on multiple levels besides payment-dependent notes, including Regulation A+ (the small offering exemption) and crowdfunding – all of which allow the SEC to grant state law preemption under the JOBS Act of 2012.  State regulators have a powerful lobbying force and may be able to successfully fight federal preemption efforts.  Moreover, states are forming a national registration system to counter claims that the state-by-state approval process is too cumbersome.

Will Lending Club Become Available to Investors in All 50 States?

So will Lending Club’s payment-dependent notes become available to investors in all 50 states after the IPO? Lending Club has written a risk factor in its IPO prospectus that preemption from state law is not a certainty.  As a result, we could see some new states accept federal preemption and begin to offer payment-dependent notes while others may fight, causing a delay.  If multiple states take different views of the same language of federal law (“pari passu or senior”) then the decision will be decided by the SEC and ultimately the courts, which will have  far-reaching implications beyond peer-to-peer.

Thus, it is not clear on whether Lending Club’s payment-dependent notes will become available to investors in states that currently do not permit the sale of notes. If a few states decide to fight the preemption issue, then it could force this issue into the court systems and meaningfully delay any action.  If the states decide not to fight the preemption issue, then Lending Club’s notes could be rolled out if all 50 states sooner rather than later.  In the meantime, many industry observers are watching this legal drama with great interest.

This article first appeared on Lend Academy.

Tags: , , , , , ,


AZCentral.comTiny companies lure investors under Arizona crowdfunding lawAZCentral.comInvestors who make bets under the state's one-year-old crowdfunding law certainly have the potential to get in on the ground floor, but they must be patient and might not receive any returns. Th [...]

BloombergCouples Desperate For Children Turn to Crowdfunding FertilityBloombergCrowdfunding has become a popular mechanism for many couples who can't afford the high costs of IVF, or adoption and surrogacy. “It's not an easy thing to share publicly,” says Crystal Barrett, 33 [...]

WTTV CBS4IndyCrowdfunding effort to save Dorothy's iconic ruby red slippers from 'Wizard of Oz' raises $300000WTTV CBS4IndyThe Smithsonian has launched a campaign on Kickstarter aimed at raising $300,000 to preserve the ruby red slippers worn by Judy Garland in the belo [...]

Crowdfund InsiderMassive Rule 147 Amendments May Be On The Horizon Impacting ...Crowdfund InsiderAlmost a year ago, the SEC proposed certain amendments to the current Rule 147 which were intended to help foster, and increase the viability of, Intrastat.and more » [...]

Mountain XpressFaces in the crowd: WNC crowdfunding initatives | Mountain XpressMountain XpressEach week, Xpress highlights notable WNC crowdsourcing initiatives that may inspire readers to become new faces in the crowd. This week features a feature ...and more » [...]

MarketWatchWhy a crowdfunding site is giving out $10000 scholarshipsMarketWatchCrowdfunding site GoFundMe announced Thursday that it will award $10,000 to 10 students with pages on their site that fundraise for education. The award is part of a contest the site held throughout Septemb [...]

Android Authority (blog)Crowdfunding project of the week: Remix IO is an Android 4K set-top ...Android Authority (blog)The 'Crowdfunding project of the week' series is where we highlight some of the hottest campaigns from sites like Kickstarter and Indiegogo. There's pl [...]

Huffington PostReal Estate Crowdfunding's Pathway of ChangeHuffington Post“Crowdfunding is just the Internet,” stated Attorney Mark Roderick as he opened last month's RealCap Chicago. RealCap is an annual conference that joins crowdfunding leaders and innovators to propel th [...]

WestwordProgressive-Rock Band Marillion Pioneered CrowdfundingWestwordThat was the beginning of crowdfunding for us — and for every band, really.” When it came time for the recording and release of the followup to the 1999 marillion.com record, Kelly and the band realized that one of [...]

BBC NewsNHS trust 'relies' on crowdfunding to equip wardBBC NewsAn NHS trust has launched a crowdfunding appeal to buy equipment for a new hospital unit because "it cannot get started without donations". The Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital (RNOH) in Stanmore, n [...]

CFB Finance

Press Release

CrowdFund Beat News

Hello @CrowdFundBeat's 17330 followers - thank you so much for following! Wishing you all a happy Monday! >> bit.ly/_want_this_free

Live Crowdfunding .tv

What's Next Step in Regulation A+ JOBS ACTS Title IIII :L Interview : Steve Cinelli with Brian Korn Securities and Crowdfunding/Peer-to-Peer Lending Lawyer, Watch more video library | Conference | Interview | Campaign Showcase | Research | Education |